Friday, April 29, 2011

Mel Kiper Gets Only 9 Right in First Round

Pro Football weekly got 12 out of 32. Mel Kiper, 9 out of 32.
Interestingly, both had two where they got the right player, but the wrong team (#6 Julio Jones to Atlanta, and #28 Mark Ingram to New Orleans). If we tossed those out, Kiper would have 7/32. With that kind of track record, should we really have to listen to this boob for months? I'm looking for Todd McShay's picks to see if he did any better, but of course, ESPN keeps these locked up as paid content.

ACTUAL PICK

PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY

MEL KIPER

1. Carolina Panthers: Auburn QB Cam Newton

1 Carolina Cam Newton QB Auburn

1. Carolina - QB Cam Newton

2. Denver Broncos: Texas A&M OLB Von Miller

2 Denver Von Miller OLB Texas A&M

2. Denver - OLB Von Miller

3. Buffalo Bills: Alabama DT Marcell Dareus

3 Buffalo Marcell Dareus DT Alabama

3. Buffalo - DT Marcell Dareus

4. Cincinnati Bengals: Georgia WR A.J. Green

4 Cincinnati A.J. Green WR Georgia

4. Cincinnati - WR A.J. Green

5. Arizona Cardinals: LSU CB Patrick Peterson

5 Arizona Patrick Peterson CB LSU

5. Arizona - Patrick Peterson

6. Atlanta Falcons: Alabama WR Julio Jones

6 Cleveland Julio Jones WR Alabama

6. Cleveland - Julio Jones

7. San Francisco 49ers: Missouri OLB Aldon Smith

7 San Francisco Blaine Gabbert QB Missouri

7. San Francisco - QB Blaine Gabbert

8. Tennessee Titans: Washington QB Jake Locker

8 Tennessee Nick Fairley DT Auburn

8. Tennessee - Nick Fairley

9. Dallas Cowboys: USC OT Tyron Smith

9 Dallas Tyron Smith T USC

9. Dallas - DE Cameron Jordan

10. Jacksonville Jaguars: Missouri QB Blaine Gabbert

10 Washington Cameron Jordan DE California

10. Washington - DE Robert Quinn

11. Houston Texans: Wisconsin DE J.J. Watt

11 Houston J.J. Watt DE Wisconsin

11. Houston - DE Aldon Smith

12. Minnesota Vikings: FSU QB Christian Ponder

12 Minnesota Aldon Smith DE Missouri

12. Minnesota - QB Jake Locker

13. Detroit Lions: Auburn DT Nick Fairley

13 Detroit Prince Amukamara CB Nebraska

13. Detroit - OT Tyron Smith

14. St. Louis Rams: UNC DE Robert Quinn

14 St. Louis Corey Liuget DT Illinois

14. St. Louis - DT Corey Liuget

15. Florida G/C Mike Pouncey

15 Miami Mike Pouncey G Florida

15. Miami - OL Mike Pouncey

16. Washington Redskins: Purdue DE Ryan Kerrigan

16 Jacksonville Robert Quinn DE North Carolina

16. Jacksonville - DE Ryan Kerrigan

17. New England Patriots: Colorado OT Nate Solder

17 New England Christian Ponder QB Florida St.

17. New England - DT Muhammad Wilkerson

18. San Diego Chargers: Illinois DT Corey Liguet

18 San Diego Ryan Kerrigan DE Purdue

18. San Diego - DE J.J. Watt

19. New York Giants: Nebraska CB Prince Amukamara

19 NY Giants Anthony Castonzo T Boston Coll.

19. New York Giants - OT Anthony Castonzo

20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Iowa DE Adrian Clayborn

20 Tampa Bay Adrian Clayborn DE Iowa

20. Tampa Bay - CB Prince Amukamara

21. Cleveland Browns: Baylor NT Phil Taylor

21 Kansas City Phil Taylor DT Baylor

21. Kansas City - OT Gabe Carimi

22. Indianapolis Colts: Boston College OT Anthony Costanzo

22 Indianapolis Jimmy Smith CB Colorado

22. Indianapolis - OT Nate Solder

23. Philadelphia Eagles: Baylor G Danny Watkins

23 Philadelphia

23. Philadelphia - CB Jimmy Smith

24. New Orleans Saints: California DE Cameron Jordan

24 New Orleans Muhammad Wilkerson DE Temple

24. New Orleans - DE Da'Quan Bowers

25. Seattle Seahawks: Alabama G James Carpenter

25 Seattle Andy Dalton QB TCU

25. Seattle - QB Andy Dalton

26. Kansas City Chiefs: Pittsburgh WR Jonathon Baldwin

26 Baltimore Derek Sherrod T Mississippi St.

26. Baltimore - LB Akeem Ayers

27. Baltimore Ravens: Colorado CB Jimmy Smith

27 Atlanta Ryan Mallett QB Arkansas

27. Atlanta - DE Adrian Clayborn

28. New Orleans Saints: Alabama RB Mark Ingram

28 New England Mark Ingram RB Alabama

28. New England - RB Mark Ingram

29. Chicago Bears: Wisconsin OT Gabe Carimi

29 Chicago Marvin Austin DT North Carolina

29. Chicago - OT Derek Sherrod

30. New York Jets: Temple DE Muhammad Wilkerson

30 NY Jets Akeem Ayers OLB UCLA

30. New York Jets - DT Phil Taylor

31. Pittsburgh Steelers: Ohio State DE Cameron Heyward

31 Pittsburgh Aaron Williams FS Texas

31. Pittsburgh - CB Aaron Williams

32. Green Bay Packers: Mississippi State OT Derek Sherrod

32 Green Bay Justin Houston OLB Georgia

32. Green Bay - OG Danny Watkins

No comments:

Post a Comment